Why indias supreme court allowed linking aadhaar with pan. My reservations should be seen as a difference of opinion not an indictment, rejection or the contempt of the court. In an order with wide ramifications, the supreme court on tuesday ruled that aadhar card is not mandatory for the citizens. After months of waiting, the landmark judgement of the supreme court sc on aadhaars constitutionality is finally out and, as expected, the ruling is in favour of the aadhaar act. Download full text of supreme court judgment on aadhaar. A bench led by justice v gopala gowda recalled an order of the top court. Aadhaar details of a person cannot be disclosed in the name of national security. Aadhaar card cant be made mandatory for govt welfare. Sep 26, 2018 the supreme court judgment stated that linking of your pan card and aadhaar is mandatory. It has also laid down the services for which aadhaar card is mandatory read article.
Mar, 2018 the supreme court today extended the march 31 aadhaar deadline till it delivers its final verdict on the entire case and said that the uidai card is not mandatory for banking, phone and passport services for now. After supreme court verdict, what needs to be linked with. Further we present various cases in which aadhaar card may pose security threats. The sc said no person will be denied benefits under social welfare scheme because of failure of authentication through aadhaar. The supreme court has said that schools cannot demand aadhaar from children at the time of admissions. The supreme court countered some of the aadhaarsurveillance arguments with an observation that similar data collection happens when a person uses an iphone or an atm. Aadhaar not mandatory for enrolment in neet, supreme court.
Sep 26, 2018 a 5judge constitutional bench of the supreme court on wednesday upheld the constitutional validity of aadhaar scheme. The supreme court of india issued an interim order on 23 september 20 saying that no person should suffer for not. In fact, in 20 itself, the apex court had said, no person should suffer for not getting an aadhaar card. Aug 11, 2015 rejecting the governments plea, the supreme court said it will now have to publicise widely that the aadhaar card was not mandatory.
Supreme court rules aadhaar not mandatory for social benefits. The supreme courts aadhaar judgement has clarified the law on the services where the government cannot insist on the aadhaar card. Heres a list of services where aadhaar is not required. A 5judge constitutional bench of the supreme court on wednesday upheld the constitutional validity of aadhaar scheme. Thats despite an august 2015 supreme court order pdf restraining the. Sep 26, 2018 supreme court upheld the validity of aadhaar, but imposed some restrictions on its use. Notably, when the provision for aadhar card was initiated it was clarified that aadhar. Aadhar card not mandatory to avail schemes, rules supreme court. Aadhaaract the supreme court judgment stated that linking of your pan card and aadhaar is mandatory. Supreme court upholds constitutional validity of aadhaar. Mar 27, 2017 countering the government push to make aadhaar compulsory for access to social welfare schemes, the supreme court on tuesday said obtaining the 12digit unique identification number, which. Supreme court upheld the validity of aadhaar, but imposed some restrictions on its use. File photo reminding the central government that aadhaar cannot be made mandatory for any services, the supreme court has ordered it to remove a condition making it mandatory for the students to give their aadhaar numbers for various scholarship schemes.
Sep 26, 2018 the supreme court wednesday declared the centres flagship aadhaar scheme as constitutionally valid but struck down some of its provisions including its linking with bank accounts, mobile phones. Supreme court says aadhaar card is mandatory for getting a pan card, filing itr but not for mobile phone connections and bank accounts. Aadhaar is mandatory for pan card linking, said the apex court. Judges rule aadhaar card not mandatory for government. In the most awaited matter, supreme court of india on wednesday declared its verdict on central governments aadhaar card scheme and regarded it as constitutionally valid. Mar 28, 2018 the supreme court today refused to pass an interim order extending the deadline of march 31 for linking of aadhaar with the welfare schemes where benefits are transferred to citizens from the consolidated fund of india. The centre and state governments must not insist on aadhaar from citizens before providing essential services, the apex court ruled in a significant development, the supreme court on monday has ruled that aadhaar or the unique identification uid number, the united progressive alliance upas ambitious scheme, is not mandatory to avail essential services from the. Supreme court ruling will only strengthen aadhaar, says uidai chief. The supreme court held that while aadhaar would remain mandatory for filing of income tax returns itr and allotment of permanent account number pan, it would not be mandatory to. Section 3 present case studies in which the implementation of aadhaar card may lead to security threats. On september 26, 2018, a constitution bench of the supreme court, led by chief justice of india dipak misra upheld the validity of aadhaar but with riders. Before central government challenging to adhaar in the court it pushing persons to link up their adhaar to various documents like mobile sim card,bank accounts,etc.
Why is the supreme court not allowing the aadhaar card to. Aadhaar valid but conditions apply, supreme court decides. What do you think about the supreme court judgement on. In the 20 order, the apex court had directed that no person should suffer for not getting the aadhaar card, inspite of the fact that some authority had issued a circular making it mandatory. However, you can also provide aadhaar card for verification as it is optional and not invalid. The hearing of the validity of aadhar is currently progressing in the supreme court of india with a five judge bench taking over the issue. Here is a list of services where aadhaar linking is mandatory and where it is. Supreme court rules aadhaar not mandatory for bank. Aadhaar cant be mandatory for opening bank accounts or mobile phone connections, or for school admissions, rules supreme court. Indias supreme court has come down heavily on the mandatory linking of.
Supreme court orders linking aadhaar card with pan card mandatory. Court said the program is not mandatory for bank accounts, sims. Having said so, it becomes clear from the aforesaid discussion that those who are not pan holders, while applying for pan, they are required to give aadhaar number. Supreme court upholds constitutional validity of aadhaar with. You can provide another government id proof for verification. Here is all you need to know about the implications of the aadhaar verdict. This was a mass activity happening in india and every mobile number operator and bank account was behind the customer to link their phone with their aadhaar.
Aadhaar is also not needed for admission in schools while as it is mandatory to link pan card with aadhaar and it is a must for filing income tax returns. Supreme court raps centre for making aadhar mandatory catch. The supreme court of india, today gave a decision that linking aadhar card with pan card is not mandatory for people who dont have an aadhar card and those who have not yet applied for it. The supreme court also ruled that aadhaar card would not be mandatory for school admissions or any examinations conducted by the central board of secondary examination cbse, national eligibility cum entrance test neet for medical entrance and the university grants commission ugc.
It is mandatory to link permanent account number pan with aadhaar. Supreme court has finally made an official announcement that it is mandatory to link an aadhaar card with pan card to file it returns. Though the verdict delivered by a fivejudge constitution bench of the supreme court on the validity of aadhaar has upheld most of the provisions in the aadhaar act and also ruled that it does not breach privacy, it has struck down several provisions that could have infringed privacy or gave unnecessary exposure to personal information. Rejecting the governments plea, the supreme court said it will now have to publicise widely that the aadhaar card was not mandatory. First thing is that in menaka gandhi vs union of india1978 case supream court declared many rights such as right to privacy, right to in. Supreme courts judgement on aadhaar find out the impact. The fivejudge constitution bench of supreme court, led by chief justice dipak misra, struck down section 57 of the aadhaar act which allowed not only the government but also any private entity to. It would mean that those who would not be possessing aadhaar card as on july 01, 2017 may. The supreme court has unequivocally stated as follows. Sep 24, 20 the supreme court of india on 23 september 20 held that aadhaar cards or unique identification number uid will not be mandatory for availing services or benefits under government schemes like. The section makes quoting of the aadhaar number mandatory while applying for a pan. The court has dispersed for lunch and will reassemble at 2. Court says aadhaar linking is not mandatory for bank accounts and mobile phones, but a must for pan.
This was headed by justice jasti chelameswar the court further said that no person should be denied any benefits or suffer for not. Apr 18, 2020 aadhaar not mandatory for school admissions. Linking aadhar card with pan card is now partially mandatory. Aadhaar not mandatory for bank accounts supreme court rules.
Indias top lawyers, arguing against the validity of aadhaar in the supreme court, have highlighted concerns about everything from possible citizen profiling and state control to denial of public services and hasty passage of the law making the biometric id mandatory. How to update aadhar card online e aadhar card download. Sep 26, 2018 the supreme courts aadhaar judgement has clarified the law on the services where the government cannot insist on the aadhaar card. The fivejudge bench ruled that the aadhaar programme served the larger public interest in ensuring that the poor have access to resources. But incidentally, the supreme court has been stating that there is no way that aadhar can be made mandatory. Is it not mandatory to provide aadhaar to open bank accounts, get sim cards, or for services from.
India supreme court verdict on constitutional validity. For understanding why apex court is not making adhaar card to be compulsory we have to understand two things. The supreme court repealed section 33 2 of the aadhaar act. The bench also asked how data collection via aadhaar was different from data collection via a pan card linked to the income tax department, say. In a major judgment, the constitution bench of supreme court on tuesday ruled that aadhar card can be used for availing government schemes but it is not necessary. All about aadhaar verdict the supreme court has passed the verdict on 27 th september 2018 that you no longer need to link your aadhaar to mobile phones and bank accounts. This is what the supreme court did not like about aadhaar. Oct 01, 2018 in effect, the supreme court has endorsed section 9aa of the indian income tax act, introduced in budget 2017.
The supreme court of india on 23 september 20 held that aadhaar cards or unique identification number uid will not be mandatory for availing services or benefits under government schemes like. In the september 2018 judgment, the supreme court nevertheless stipulated that the aadhaar card is not mandatory for opening bank accounts, getting a mobile number, or being admitted to a school. However, the apex court announced that aadhaar card is not mandatory for opening bank accounts, mobile connections, and for taking admission in schoolscolleges. The supreme court said the government will now have to publicise widely that the aadhaar card was not mandatory. Adhaar is the most sophisticated and most unique id programming system in the world. Aadhaar linking not mandatory for bank accounts, phones for. Supreme court rules aadhaar not mandatory for bank accounts, mobile numbers, school admissions.
However, the supreme court of indias ruling on aadhar scheme may be viewed as a setback to the central upa 2 government and some state governments which started making obtaining the aadhar card number, mandatory, directly or indirectly. Mar 28, 2018 aadhar card is not a mandatory document as was recently ruled by the supreme court of india. The supreme court of india has ordered that the government should not restrict social benefits to those who are yet to receive their aadhaar card and not to issue the card to illegal migrants. In their cases, the enrolment id of aadhaar application form is to be quoted. The observations of supreme court of india are also presented in this paper. The supreme court has announced that for now, citizens do not have to link their aadhaar numbers to a range of services. Sep 24, 20 the supreme court of india has ordered that the government should not restrict social benefits to those who are yet to receive their aadhaar card and not to issue the card to illegal migrants. Jun 14, 2017 for understanding why apex court is not making adhaar card to be compulsory we have to understand two things. The 12digit unique number for each citizen does not have to. In a landmark verdict on the aadhaar act, the supreme court upheld its constitutional validity and listed out a number of services where aadhaar is not required. Aadhaar not mandatory for bank account, mobile number but.
Bank accounts and mobile phone no longer need to be linked, but pan card and incometax returns still require. Jun 11, 2017 aadhar needed for pan card registration. Sep 26, 2018 indias supreme court has come down heavily on the mandatory linking of aadhaar for almost everything. For clients who are not beneficiaries of the aforesaid welfare schemes or who do not. Attorney general mukul rohatgi told the apex court they have found that a number of pan cards. Aadhaar not mandatory compulsary in india supreme court of india. The supreme court today asked the government to explain why the aadhar card is still being treated as mandatory by the government for citizens who want to get their marriages or property. The supreme court of india in its judgment of a writ petition filed by justice k s puttaswamy retd. Follow live updates on supreme court verdict on aadhaar. Aug 11, 2015 in a major judgment, the constitution bench of supreme court on tuesday ruled that aadhar card can be used for availing government schemes but it is not necessary. The court also ruled that the information obtained through uid can not be shared for any other purpose except for criminal investigation and that too with the courts approval.
The supreme court s aadhaar judgement has clarified the law on the services where the government cannot insist on the aadhaar card. Final government, supreme court decision link aadhar card. In section 4 the observations of the honourable supreme court of india are discussed. The supreme court of india, today gave a decision that linking aadhar card with pan card is not mandatory for people who dont have an aadhar card and those who have not yet applied for it however, people who already have an aadhar card have to. The court ruled out biometric id as mandatory for accessing welfare schemes and subsidies. Aadhar has been facing a sufficient amount of criticism ever since it was proposed. March 31 was the earlier deadline to link aadhaar to bank accounts and mobile phones.
Aadhar card is a voluntary id document that every legal resident of india can avail irrespective of their present documentation. The supreme court judgment stated that linking of your pan card and aadhaar is mandatory. Aadhar card search by village wise list step by step guide. In effect, the supreme court has endorsed section 9aa of the indian income tax act, introduced in budget 2017. It also ruled that no authority shall seek aadhaar cards from. Aadhaar not mandatory for bank accounts supreme court. Matter was heard at length by a three judges bench of this court and detailed arguments were. What is aadhaar mandatory for and what is it not mandatory. Judges rule card not mandatory for government subsidies. The supreme court has passed a historic and landmark verdict. Aug 11, 2015 in an order with wide ramifications, the supreme court on tuesday ruled that aadhar card is not mandatory for the citizens. The court said, aadhaar does not infringe on an individuals right to privacy.
The supreme court today asked the government to explain why the aadhar card is still being treated as mandatory by the government. Supreme court rules aadhaar not mandatory for bank accounts, mobile numbers, school admissions justice a k sikri, who is part of the fivejudge bench ruling on the validity of the aadhaar act and who wrote the majority judgment, also struck down section 57 of aadhaar act, which permits private entities to avail of aadhaar data. Earlier, the delhi high court has made an official judgment saying that there is no need to link aadhaar with pan in a mandatory manner in order to file tax returns for 201819. This is the stipulation of subsection 1 of section 9aa, which we have already upheld. Jan 26, 2019 i disagree with the judgement but intend to fully honor it. The supreme court of india has cleared all the doubts regarding the validity of aadhar card to avail of government subsidies. Supreme court says aadhaar not necessary for essential. After supreme court verdict, what needs to be linked with aadhaar and what doesnt. Supreme court rules aadhaar not mandatory for bank accounts. The supreme court today said that the aadhaar unique identity system will not be compulsory for indian. A 5member constitution bench of the supreme court led by chief justice dipak misra ruled that aadhaar is mandatory. Supreme court rules aadhaar not mandatory for social. At the same time, sc has also upheld mandatory linkage of aadhaar with pan card and. The supreme court today directed the cbse not to make aadhaar number mandatory for enrolment of students appearing in neet 2018 and other allindia exams.
The court also asked the government to give widespread publicity through various media that aadhar is not mandatory. It has also laid down the services for which aadhaar card is mandatory. The same thing was said by the supreme court on friday, which has been cleared by the government. Aadhar card is not mandatory, rules supreme court youtube. In this paper, section 2 discusses the scope and advantages of linking aadhaar card to various systems. The sc has confirmed that the aadhar card is not compulsory, and further, officials who insist on them will be taken to task. In a major judgment, the supreme court on tuesday said that aadhar card will be optional for availing various welfare schemes of the government. The supreme court on wednesday said aadhaar is not needed for opening a bank account, or getting a sim card and private companies cannot ask for aadhaar details. Why is the supreme court not allowing the aadhaar card to be. On march 27, the supreme court ordered that the government cannot be stopped from using aadhaar identification for its nonwelfare schemes like opening of bank accounts, filing of tax returns, verification of new and existing mobile phone numbers and user credentials etc. Todays verdict concludes a 38day hearing held over four months, the secondlongest oral hearing in history after the kesavananda bharati case.
Aadhaar card is not mandatory as address or identity proof any more. Supreme courts judgement on aadhaar find out the impact on. Judges rule aadhaar card not mandatory for government subsidies. Aadhaar card cant be made mandatory for govt welfare schemes. According to the statement issued by the cbdt, aadhaar number and enrollment id must be mentioned in all the pan cards formed from july 1 and also required.
401 459 849 1290 251 530 501 28 249 1308 1495 163 221 1338 12 509 538 658 1404 664 46 1249 267 842 252 609 522 428 712 382 766 1314 122 611 611 197 541 152 1174 488